Executive Summary
The Islamic values and cultural practices of American
Muslims can play a role in community health disparities by influencing health
behaviors and healthcare-seeking patterns and presenting challenges within the
healthcare system. To date, scant empirical research has been conducted in
collaboration with this community in order to better understand their beliefs
and perceived challenges. This report is based on the analysis of qualitative
data from semi-structured interviews and focus groups collected through a
community-based participatory project with American Muslims living in
southeastern Michigan. Specifically, our aim was to (1) identify key health
beliefs and practices within the community, (2) gain a better understanding of
these beliefs and practices and how they may impact the seeking of healthcare
services, and (3) identify clinical situations that pose cultural challenges
within healthcare. This report provides an overview of American Muslim health
beliefs, describes how these beliefs impact healthcare-seeking practices, and
recommends accommodations that can improve the healthcare experience of
American Muslim patients. Understanding the links between Islamic beliefs and
practices and their influence on clinical encounters provides opportunities to
improve community health and deliver culturally sensitive high quality care.
Introduction
Research has demonstrated that minority patient populations
receive a lower quality of care and face significant challenges when trying to
access and receive healthcare. Among
racial and ethnic groups, health disparities persist due to the confluence of structural,
institutional, and interpersonal factors. Overcoming these barriers and
disparities requires that the beliefs, priorities, and healthcare needs of
minority communities be understood and accommodated. Health disparities among
religious minorities merit particular consideration, as religious values are
very influential in an individual’s and group’s development and articulation of
the concept of “health.” Thus, a better understanding of how religious values
influence health behaviors can result in the delivery of more culturally
sensitive healthcare services.
American Muslims are a fast-growing, under-studied, and
underserved minority. While ethnically and racially diverse, they are bound
together by a shared religious tradition that shapes their worldview and
informs their behavior. The major ethnic groups within the American Muslim
community are indigenous African Americans, South Asians, and Arabs. American
Muslims may share religiously informed views on health, illness, and the
healing process. For example, many aspects of healthcare may be informed by
individual and personal practices of Islam- from conceptions of disease and
cure to healthcare-seeking patterns and decision-making. When considering the
healthcare needs of American Muslim patients, providers must be aware of the
wide spectrum of adherence, religious practice, rituals, and traditions within
this community. Nonetheless, areas of shared concern between different segments
of this population exist and are the focus of our project. Increasing cultural competence has been cited
as part of the solution to reduce health disparities; however, “Muslim patient
cultural guides” are predominantly based on provider experiences as opposed to
empirical research conducted in collaboration with the community. To better
understand the factors that influence American Muslim health barriers and
challenges, we embarked on a community-based participatory research project.
This report presents an overview of American Muslim health beliefs, describes
how these beliefs impact healthcare-seeking practices, and recommends
accommodations that can improve the healthcare experience of American Muslim
patients.